The Search Continues for the Youngest Varsity High School Football Coach Ever

high school football coaches
gamestrat sideline instant replay header

What started as a simple story about Pen Argyl High School (Pennsylvania) hiring 23-year old Brady Mutton as its new head coach, is now a full-fledged search. When I saw Coach Mutton’s age, it put me on a mission — who is the youngest head varsity football coach ever in America?

To this point, we’ve had a lot of people helping with this nationwide search. For readers of the first version of this story, you discovered that Brady Mutton is not.

That honor, as of Wednesday, went to current Roseville (California) head coach Joe Cattolico, who was 22-years old when he was hired before the 1997 season by Overfelt High School in San Jose, California. In just his second season at the helm of Overfelt, Cattolico led the program to a California Central Coast Section II championship.

Now, four days later, there’s another coach in the running for the youngest ever in America.

I’ve been in-touch with current Brownsburg (Indiana) head coach John Hart, who became the head coach at Edwards County High School in Albion, Illinois in 1985 at the age of 22-years old. Coach Hart estimates that he was 22-years, 5 months old when he was hired by Edwards County.

Hart has won two Indiana state championships — Evansville Reitz in 2007 and Warren Central in 2009.

So, here’s the deal…we’re waiting to hear from Coach Cattolico to find-out how old he was when he was hired at Overfelt. However, please feel free to email me, if you know of any other coach 22-years old or young, please email us.

Editor’s Note: During our research we found other young varsity head football coaches that we’d like to salute. They are listed below.

Mark Bates, 23 – Los Angeles Baptist (California), 1998 *currently the head coach at Santa Clarita Christian School (California)

Phil Chrys, 23 – Weedsport Central HS (New York), 1977

Adam Colman, 23 – Burbank HS (California), 2017

Noel Dean, 23 – Burton Bendle HS (Michigan), 1991

Danny Esparza, 23 – West Valley HS (Alaska), 2009 *

Mitchell Parsley – Crowell HS (Texas), 2019

Joe Ryan, 23 – Eureka HS (Illinois), 1993 *currently the head coach at Sycamore HS (Illinois)

Small Player Big Play

small player big play

No More Fumbles

About the Author

Jeff Fisher
Jeff is an award-winning journalist and expert in the field of high school sports, underscored with his appearance on CNBC in 2010 to talk about the big business of high school football in America. Jeff turned to his passion for high school football into an entrepreneurial venture called High School Football America, a digital media company focused on producing original high school sports content for radio, television and the internet. Jeff is co-founder and editor-in-chief of High School Football America, which is a media partner with USA TODAY High School Sports.